I would really like to know where people like Soderberg get the idea that the U.S. President has the power to “order” private citizens to do anything, let alone to break the law, as even she admits happened here. I’m asking this literally: how did this warped and distinctly un-American mentality get implanted into our public discourse — that the President can give “orders” to private citizens that must be complied with? Soderberg views the President as a monarch — someone who can issue “orders” that must be obeyed, even when, as she acknowledges, the “orders” are illegal.
One of the reasons I have a hard time following Glenn Greenwald is that he has a habit of devoting looooong pieces to topics that require two or three paragraphs, tops. But I do find it interesting that Glenn, along with what is in my estimation a sizable majority of the liberal blogosphere, treats the status of being “American” as an immutable value. The idea of an all powerful, imperial executive is hardly “un-American” in today’s political culture. In our current power-worshiping, hero-lionizing milieu, it’s as American as a gas-guzzling hummer that you don’t need. In all honesty we should simply admit that the republic, to the extent that it ever truly existed post-Spanish American war, is dead and buried. All that’s left is for America as it currently is, i.e. the USEmpire, to burn away in all it’s self-destructive, violent glory.
Should be interesting.
July 6, 2008 at 11:33 pm
Damn you can be a depressing bastard sometimes.
July 7, 2008 at 12:04 am
I guess I’m contagious…
EDIT: AND I FINALLY MANAGED TO GET RID OF THOSE ANNOYING SNAPSHOT THINGS! I IZ R SPECIAL!!!
EDIT II: Don’t know why I’m editing again, guess I’m just punchy. I want to crap myself. What is needed in this situation is caffeine.
July 7, 2008 at 11:15 am
Ah, essentialist thinking.
It’s the same game as when a self-described “religious moderate” gets in your face about how no true Scotsman — beg pardon, no true Christian — has a problem with evolution.
July 7, 2008 at 6:59 pm
And indeed, Christianity and American exceptionalism have quite a bit in common. Commitment to fantastical notions, a belief in inherent superiority, and now with Obama, the worship of a hollow savior.